ID: 2405.15042

Modularity, Higher-Order Recombination, and New Venture Success

May 23, 2024

View on ArXiv
Likun Cao, Ziwen Chen, James Evans
Economics
Econometrics

Modularity is critical for the emergence and evolution of complex social, natural, and technological systems robust to exploratory failure. We consider this in the context of emerging business organizations, which can be understood as complex systems. We build a theory of organizational emergence as higher-order, modular recombination wherein successful start-ups assemble novel combinations of successful modular components, rather than engage in the lower-order combination of disparate, singular components. Lower-order combinations are critical for long-term socio-economic transformation, but manifest diffuse benefits requiring support as public goods. Higher-order combinations facilitate rapid experimentation and attract private funding. We evaluate this with U.S. venture-funded start-ups over 45 years using company descriptions. We build a dynamic semantic space with word embedding models constructed from evolving business discourse, which allow us to measure the modularity of and distance between new venture components. Using event history models, we demonstrate how ventures more likely achieve successful IPOs and high-priced acquisitions when they combine diverse modules of clustered components. We demonstrate how higher-order combination enables venture success by accelerating firm development and diversifying investment, and we reflect on its implications for social innovation.

Similar papers 1

Predicting success in the worldwide start-up network

April 17, 2019

86% Match
Moreno Bonaventura, Valerio Ciotti, Pietro Panzarasa, Silvia Liverani, ... , Latora Vito
Physics and Society
Data Analysis, Statistics an...

By drawing on large-scale online data we construct and analyze the time-varying worldwide network of professional relationships among start-ups. The nodes of this network represent companies, while the links model the flow of employees and the associated transfer of know-how across companies. We use network centrality measures to assess, at an early stage, the likelihood of the long-term positive performance of a start-up, showing that the start-up network has predictive powe...

Find SimilarView on arXiv
T. M. A. Fink, M. Reeves, ... , Farr R. S.
Physics and Society
General Finance

Innovation is to organizations what evolution is to organisms: it is how organisations adapt to changes in the environment and improve. Governments, institutions and firms that innovate are more likely to prosper and stand the test of time; those that fail to do so fall behind their competitors and succumb to market and environmental change. Yet despite steady advances in our understanding of evolution, what drives innovation remains elusive. On the one hand, organizations in...

Innovation and Evolution of Business Relations and Networks: Theory and Method

March 6, 2012

85% Match
Ian The University of Sydney and University of Southern Denmark Wilkinson, Louise University of Western Sydney and University of Southern Denmark Young
Adaptation and Self-Organizi...

We introduce a complex systems perspective on innovation in networks in which innovation is conceptualized as a form of creative act associated with the dynamics and evolution of business network. We show how innovation is a form of creative act that involves the creation of new ideas and their exploitation, in which new ideas come from combining and recombining existing ideas in new ways that have value. We stress the need to move away from traditional linear, comparative st...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

The Science of Startups: The Impact of Founder Personalities on Company Success

February 15, 2023

85% Match
Paul X. McCarthy, Xian Gong, Fabian Stephany, Fabian Braesemann, ... , Kern Margaret L.
General Economics
Economics

Startup companies solve many of today's most complex and challenging scientific, technical and social problems, such as the decarbonisation of the economy, air pollution, and the development of novel life-saving vaccines. Startups are a vital source of social, scientific and economic innovation, yet the most innovative are also the least likely to survive. The probability of success of startups has been shown to relate to several firm-level factors such as industry, location ...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

Investor-patent networks as mutualistic networks

November 30, 2023

85% Match
Théophile Carniel, Léo Cazenille, ... , Halloy José
Physics and Society

Venture capital investments in startups have come to represent an important driver of technological innovation, in parallel to corporate- and government-directed efforts. Part of the future of artificial intelligence, medicine and quantum computing now depends upon a large number of venture investment decisions whose robustness against increasingly frequent crises has therefore become crucial. To shed light on this issue, and by combining large-scale financial, startup and pa...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

Evolution of biomedical innovation quantified via billions of distinct article-level MeSH keyword combinations

May 23, 2022

85% Match
Alexander M. Petersen
Digital Libraries
Social and Information Netwo...
General Economics
Economics

We develop a systematic approach to measuring combinatorial innovation in the biomedical sciences based upon the comprehensive ontology of Medical Subject Headings (MeSH). This approach leverages an expert-defined knowledge ontology that features both breadth (27,875 MeSH analyzed across 25 million articles indexed by PubMed from 1902 onwards) and depth (we differentiate between Major and Minor MeSH terms to identify differences in the knowledge network representation constru...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

Dropping diversity of products of large US firms: Models and measures

October 15, 2021

85% Match
Ananthan Nambiar, Tobias Rubel, James McCaull, ... , Bedau Mark
Statistical Finance
Machine Learning

It is widely assumed that in our lifetimes the products available in the global economy have become more diverse. This assumption is difficult to investigate directly, however, because it is difficult to collect the necessary data about every product in an economy each year. We solve this problem by mining publicly available textual descriptions of the products of every large US firms each year from 1997 to 2017. Although many aspects of economic productivity have been steadi...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

The Emergence of Higher-Order Structure in Scientific and Technological Knowledge Networks

September 28, 2020

85% Match
Thomas Gebhart, Russell J. Funk
Social and Information Netwo...
Algebraic Topology

The growth of science and technology is a recombinative process, wherein new discoveries and inventions are built from prior knowledge. Yet relatively little is known about the manner in which scientific and technological knowledge develop and coalesce into larger structures that enable or constrain future breakthroughs. Network science has recently emerged as a framework for measuring the structure and dynamics of knowledge. While helpful, existing approaches struggle to cap...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

The varying importance of extrinsic factors in the success of startup fundraising: competition at early-stage and networks at growth-stage

June 7, 2019

85% Match
Clement Gastaud, Theophile Carniel, Jean-Michel Dalle
General Finance
Data Analysis, Statistics an...
Physics and Society

We address the issue of the factors driving startup success in raising funds. Using the popular and public startup database Crunchbase, we explicitly take into account two extrinsic characteristics of startups: the competition that the companies face, using similarity measures derived from the Word2Vec algorithm, as well as the position of investors in the investment network, pioneering the use of Graph Neural Networks (GNN), a recent deep learning technique that enables the ...

Find SimilarView on arXiv

An Automated Startup Evaluation Pipeline: Startup Success Forecasting Framework (SSFF)

May 29, 2024

85% Match
Xisen Wang, Yigit Ihlamur
Artificial Intelligence

Evaluating startups in their early stages is a complex task that requires detailed analysis by experts. While automating this process on a large scale can significantly impact businesses, the inherent complexity poses challenges. This paper addresses this challenge by introducing the Startup Success Forecasting Framework (SSFF), a new automated system that combines traditional machine learning with advanced language models. This intelligent agent-based architecture is designe...

Find SimilarView on arXiv